Having never
been baptized in their Old Order Amish church in [fictional] Eden Valley,
Pennsylvania, in [factual] Lancaster County, formerly Amish sisters Tilly
Barrows (née Lantz) and Ruth Lantz are not shunned by their family or
community, but there remains no lack of guilt. The sisters left for completely
different reasons. Tilly, eight years Ruthie’s senior, is racked with guilt
over the death of her youngest sister, Anna, nine years ago. Tilly left Eden
Valley eight years ago and never returned. Not for a visit, not for a nostalgic-yet-secret
visit, not to introduce her family to her Englischer
husband, Kris, or their now-four-year-old identical twin daughters, Jenya and
Tavani. She also carries memories of a tough childhood, lacking the love her
dad seemed to shower on everyone but her.
Their parents, Lester and Sylvia,
are about to celebrate a hallmark wedding anniversary (40 years). Celebrating
such events, however big a milestone, is not a norm in Amish society, so the
sisters are surprised at this. Then they find out that their father’s health is
in decline. Modern medical advancements could help him, but he’s stubborn.
Their father’s worrisome health prompts Ruthie to return to Lancaster County,
but she doesn’t want to go without Tilly at her side for support. Ruthie never
married after her failed courtship with Wilmer Kauffman, nor has she forgotten
Will. Both sisters, while remaining God-fearing, faithful women, have their
individual struggles with returning to their childhood home. They seek
redemption, and, in Tilly’s case, maybe even the confirmation of love.
When they left, they didn’t turn
around and look back. What will transpire when they return? The past is past,
but can members of the Lantz family overcome the tension of years ago in less
than a week?
Lancaster County seems like such an
idyllic place, and it’s an actual county on the map. I love that, no matter
what struggles the characters are facing, faith centers them and love fills
them. Sometimes it must be re-discovered or strengthened, but it’s there. Lewis
has created another heartfelt novel of love, forgiveness, facing the past and
finding inspiration toward a brighter tomorrow. The journey through the story
isn’t fraught with danger, but it is burdened by guilt and sorrow, love lost
and love seemingly absent. Lewis is always good about tying up her stories with
a nice bow, and I like that about her books, because there is always a great
message to go along with it. Case in point: Life has thrown Tilly lemons, and
while it seems that she’s made lemonade out of those lemons, she has in fact
been harboring tart seeds of guilt for a long time. She doesn’t only need to
forgive others, but she must also forgive herself. For how can she truly move
forward when she’s dwelling on the past? How can any of us?